Best report
ϟ
Nov 3, 2016
They tried the same thing with me, but it didn't work because that particular practice -- called "negative option" -- is illegal in Alberta and in Ontario (I'm no sure about other provinces). Below is the letter I sent them and they promptly apologized, cancelled their charges and the service. I am however continuing to get calls although I asked to be on a Do Not Call List, so I'm going to follow up with the CRTC.
***************************
[written to customerservice@doctorgreen.com]
I am writing because someone from your company came by my place back on May 13 and provided a lawn service for me and for my neighbour that we did not request. The addresses and account numbers are
[addresses removed]
My neighbour and I had originally signed up for 5 treatments last summer and prepaid for the 2015 year for those 5 treatments. Neither of us requested any additional services for 2016.
I spoke to someone named Christie at extension 116 on Friday April 15, 2016 at approximately 11:20 a.m. and she told me that Dr. green provides "continual services" and expects the customer to call and cancel.
However, the practice pf providing a service (one which was not requested), then billing someone for it and requesting payment after the service was provided is illegal in Alberta. According to the Alberta Fair Trading Act Chapter F-2 section 22: "No supplier may supply goods or services to a consumer through a negative option practice."
Section 20 defines a negative option practice as:
"a consumer transaction in which a supplier (Dr. Green in this case):
(a) provides goods or services to a consumer, including the enhancement of a service that a consumer is already receiving, that the consumer did not request, and
(b) requires the consumer to pay for the goods or services unless the consumer informs the supplier that the consumer does not want the goods or services." (emphasis)
This applies if "the goods or services are provided from or received in Alberta" (section 21 b).
As such, a company cannot provide "continual" services and then require the customer to cancel them. I paid for 5 treatments in 2015 and received them, so services should have stopped after those 5 treatments.
Christie at extension 116 from your company noted that she spoke to a manager and she has cancelled both services. This was confirmed with me over the phone sometime between approximately 11:15 and 11:30 a.m on Friday April 15, 2016.
As it were, my neighbour and I have each received an invoice for $50.23. Unfortunately, since we did not request this service, we are not going to be paying these invoices - which is per the same legislation.
Again, to quote the Fair Trading Act (section 22):
"No consumer liability: A consumer is not liable to pay for any goods or services received under a negative option practice."
As such, I would ask that Dr. Green adhere to the law in Alberta by cancelling my and my neighbour's invoices and also ensuring that we will no longer receive any services from this day forward.
Please provide me with written notification that both invoices and any further service from Dr. Green has been cancelled.
I am also going to formally request that your company remove my phone number from all your phone lists and place it on a DO NOT CALL LIST. I receive multiple calls a week from a variety of numbers that, once I search for them online, belong to Dr. Green. I have requested being placed on your DO NOT CALL LIST a number of times. If I receive another call, I will file a formal complaint with the CRTC.
I am sending a copy of this email through your online system as well. I will follow up again in a few days if I not have heard a response to this email from anyone from your company. If I still don't hear back from anyone after that, I will follow up by filing a formal consumer complaint with Service Alberta and requesting an investigation.
***************************
[written to customerservice@doctorgreen.com]
I am writing because someone from your company came by my place back on May 13 and provided a lawn service for me and for my neighbour that we did not request. The addresses and account numbers are
[addresses removed]
My neighbour and I had originally signed up for 5 treatments last summer and prepaid for the 2015 year for those 5 treatments. Neither of us requested any additional services for 2016.
I spoke to someone named Christie at extension 116 on Friday April 15, 2016 at approximately 11:20 a.m. and she told me that Dr. green provides "continual services" and expects the customer to call and cancel.
However, the practice pf providing a service (one which was not requested), then billing someone for it and requesting payment after the service was provided is illegal in Alberta. According to the Alberta Fair Trading Act Chapter F-2 section 22: "No supplier may supply goods or services to a consumer through a negative option practice."
Section 20 defines a negative option practice as:
"a consumer transaction in which a supplier (Dr. Green in this case):
(a) provides goods or services to a consumer, including the enhancement of a service that a consumer is already receiving, that the consumer did not request, and
(b) requires the consumer to pay for the goods or services unless the consumer informs the supplier that the consumer does not want the goods or services." (emphasis)
This applies if "the goods or services are provided from or received in Alberta" (section 21 b).
As such, a company cannot provide "continual" services and then require the customer to cancel them. I paid for 5 treatments in 2015 and received them, so services should have stopped after those 5 treatments.
Christie at extension 116 from your company noted that she spoke to a manager and she has cancelled both services. This was confirmed with me over the phone sometime between approximately 11:15 and 11:30 a.m on Friday April 15, 2016.
As it were, my neighbour and I have each received an invoice for $50.23. Unfortunately, since we did not request this service, we are not going to be paying these invoices - which is per the same legislation.
Again, to quote the Fair Trading Act (section 22):
"No consumer liability: A consumer is not liable to pay for any goods or services received under a negative option practice."
As such, I would ask that Dr. Green adhere to the law in Alberta by cancelling my and my neighbour's invoices and also ensuring that we will no longer receive any services from this day forward.
Please provide me with written notification that both invoices and any further service from Dr. Green has been cancelled.
I am also going to formally request that your company remove my phone number from all your phone lists and place it on a DO NOT CALL LIST. I receive multiple calls a week from a variety of numbers that, once I search for them online, belong to Dr. Green. I have requested being placed on your DO NOT CALL LIST a number of times. If I receive another call, I will file a formal complaint with the CRTC.
I am sending a copy of this email through your online system as well. I will follow up again in a few days if I not have heard a response to this email from anyone from your company. If I still don't hear back from anyone after that, I will follow up by filing a formal consumer complaint with Service Alberta and requesting an investigation.